I actually like this show.*hides* Okay, sure, it has a tonne of plot falls -- I'm impressed that the dude's 15-plus year AC/DC shirt is in good condition -- but I can look past that. I can look past the vegetation growing at such a rate within the city that apparently 'life after people' fudged their estimated timeline. I can even look past the (apparent) fact that everyone's sunglasses/eye wear remained intact over 15 years. These simple little details, I can ..ignore.. Why? Because I've accepted the first part of the show's premise: The power went out.We dont know how .. the characters themselves (for the most part) dont know how. Is it actually gone or just ...muted? Its not as though they can load up google to find some comforting answers or even fire up the old ham radio to make outside contact to harness some sort of understanding of the situation; I never watched the previews but in the first episode (and its now mentioned as part of the show's intro) - people left the cities or they died. Isnt it acceptable to believe that by doing so, people left 'knowledge behind' [*]? They left their libraries, they left their school books, hell, those who did stay behind probably burnt the books to stay warm! lol What I'm saying is, I'm 32 years old and whilst I have some theoretical knowledge of how a combustible engine works, that doesnt mean I'm capable of going out to the shed and building one without doing some form of research.Another point, for those who have dismissed the show before it even began - in the very first episode, they actually say that "Physics went nuts .. it shouldn't have happened". The writers come straight out and say "hey this idea about electricity not working-yadda yadda..yeeeaaah...we know that realistically it shouldnt make sense, we know that, honestly!" And thats just to the viewer's perspective. Think about it from the perspective of the characters living through those 15 years[^]: confusion, fear, basic human survival instincts being rebooted after years (and years and years) of laying dormant.... This isnt a show where we are expected to suspend our disbelief but rather (I think) this falls in cognitive estrangement: We know we're fucked without electricity, so what happens if some device - not magical, not derived from fantasy - but an actual device built from science simply took it all away?/end rant.* = As for 'knowledge being left behind' ... well, knowledge as they say is power. The show also has a militant aspect, isnt it plausible that Monroe (oh sorry, I forgot that you dont watch the show :p) sent out garrisons to seize/destroy any and all books? ^ = Okay, I grant you that 15 years is probably a bit too of time period. Perhaps add an extra ten years?
What happens when the lights go out? What happens when the lights go out forever? Specifically, what happens when J.J. Abrams produces a show with director John Favreau about what happens 15 years after the entire world loses electricity? Well, Revolution happens, one of NBC's new shows premiering this fall. I admit, I'm kind of excited to see a series with a post-apocalyptic setting that isn't full of zombies, aliens, or other boogeymen, and I'm always a sucker for shots of things like Wrigley Frield overgrown with plants and greenery. Still, there's something about Revolution that just seems off to me. Maybe it's because of the spunky teenage girl with the bow weapon a la Hunger Games. Or maybe it's the Walking Dead/Jericho/Falling Skies-ness of it. Or maybe the mystery of where all the electricity went feels cribbed from Lost 101. Mostly, though, I think it's because it's on NBC, and my brain is no longer wired to accept that NBC could possibly make a compelling drama. Thanks to everyone who turns in the tip.
More links from around the web!
So, this is a continuation of the Day the Earth Stood Still?
Yeah, and if a shotgun can work, why can't they build a rudimentary combustion engine? For that matter, why can't you compress air using a windmill and a transmission, and use that to do work? Argh, this is going to be hard for me to watch. But I'll make an effort because of Katniss.
Glad to see I'm not the only one reading about this premise, and thinking "Wow, that's kinda... stupid".
But, then again, I have long since learned that Mr. Abrams is bereft of good ideas or the ability to form a coherent plot line.
So... a rip off of the Emberverse/Change/post-no electricity novels?http://www.amazon.com/Dies-Fir...
its just going to be another JJ Abrams cousin of Lost......it will start out with an award winning first season and maybe a second and then will try and to stretch it out for as long as they can to get and try to foster a huge internet following and throw in the odd conspiracy to get the conspiracy nuts involved and then just milk it for all its worth and then end it with an unpopular ending that only just wraps everything up but still leaves lots of plot holes open for a future min series/book/web series/fan fiction to fill in the gaps and so keep it alive online for ever.........i hated Lost the first series was fine but then it got silly.
No, no, no! Lost was carefully plotted genius from the beginning of the series! Don't you listen to the Losties out there?
Okay, so am I the only person who was most bothered by the fact that ALL THE MINORITIES in this trailer are VILLAINS??? Seriously, the opening post-apocalyptic scene was "scary black men come to hurt the pretty white people." I was hoping to see it even out through the trailer, but nope! Hopefully the show itself will be better.
You're not the only one. It's the biggest reason why I'm not going to watch this. I guess most people got stuck at "all electricity can never just stop working".
So...now a TV show is recycling music from Mass Effect 2?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v...
Or did that music come from somewhere else, and I'm too ignorant to realize it?
Everyone and their mother uses Two Steps from Hell tracks to score their trailers. Though, granted, "Heart of Courage" is pretty heavily associated with ME2 these days.
This is gonna suck. Isn't it.I couldn't even sit through the whole trailer.
The biggest problem is, J.J. Abrams has become a brand name now. He's just a producer and less hands on than his early series.Oh yeah, and it's on NBC.
So we should listen to someone like yourself, who is so jaded, ignorant and childish that they admit to hating something without even sitting through a short preview? No wonder they put you in the back of the class with the special kids.
Katniss goes for a stroll through Jeff Kirsch's "Eleventh Plague," runs into Jacob Black, and ends up on the island from LOST.
Or the fact that the lights on the plane were still working... I guess they used all their remaining power to warn off other planes, not to even attempt to safely land?
Come on dude, it's just like when you shut off your car engine whilst at freeway speeds: instant donuts, complete loss of control. Haven't you done that before?
Several Portal quips leap to mind, but they keep ricocheting off the repulsion gel and scaring the birds.
This is kinda stupid...how do car engines stop working while rifles keep firing? I mean, seriously, disconnect the computer, make a primitive engine, and then BAM, you've got a car. If stuff can still explode, we can still make cars run.
Also, how does electricity go off and not come back on? Solar flare that lasts over 15 years? That'd play havoc with our ecosystem.
I hate to be THAT nerd, but come on, can't we get a multi-million dollar budget TV show with a truly clever premise? I'm sick of shows that have a simple "what if" idea. "What if the electricity stopped working?"
It's like asking what would happen if we hadn't discovered electricity. I'll give you the answer: we'd have discovered it later. :-)
It does beg an interesting question though...are their thunder storms in this new revolutionary world?
Or they end up going the magic pixie/faeries route like Emberverse but then things stop making sense for reasons other than basic physics... like the logic of magic pixie/faeries.
I could get behind it if they said "magic did it" but they would have to hint strongly very early on or else it would be a huge let down. They could even go with a magic vs science theme about the whole thing. some people think it's magic some think it's scientifically explainable. But that's sounding a bit too Lost-ish.
They strongly hint in the video that it's technological, but then this seems (to me) heavily biased by current mainstream politics - looks very anti-green/pro-tech and anti-local/pro-federal thus serving to herd the wayward sheep of both parties. I'm guessing this puts a lot more thought into those points of view than it does logic of the setting.
Um, did everyone miss the fact that this was also created by Eric Kripke? Bad nerds. BAD.
My fear is that the entire budget was blown on the pilot. The subsequent episodes will probably involve flashbacks that conveniently take place in 2012. Or they'll just find a farm and stay there for an unnecessarily long time.
Because that would cost money it's better to rip it off and change just enough to avoid getting sued and spend the money on things that make for great television - booze and hookers for the executives.
So even batteries don't work? Someone figured out a way to just make ions stop moving? We suffered a global loss in ion conductance?!
There is no way this can work. I'd buy into it if they made up some story about how every powerplant in the world was ruined. but this...
I totally agree... The power plants and power lines may be out, as in totally wrecked, but the old water-wheel-windmill-generator would still work. That is basic physics: Move a magnet through a coil of wire and electrons flow. Plus military bases are infamous for their backups for their backups... Even 15 years later there would STILL be a LOT of battery-powered devices that would still be workable, not to mention all of the "Survival" gear/devices that have built in power generators/solar panels.
When the world went dark, people also lost the power to read. Or aircraft dropping out of the sky incinerated every library. For whatever reason, ye tech of olde was lost. Among the few salvageable bits was a pamphlet detailing how to craft scoop-neck, curve-hugging tees in a bright, modern hue. Probably from hemp.
"Mostly, though, I think it's because it's on NBC, and my brain is no longer wired to accept that NBC could possibly make a compelling drama. Thanks to everyone who turns in the tip."
Clearly someone hasn't been watching Awake. Which is why it got cancelled. Way to go Rob, you killed the only new show this season that I liked >=(
This is a combination of hunger games, book of eli, and several other stories... Yet ANOTHER NBC series to be ignored and cancelled after less than a full season. And so predictable that after seeing this I already know what is going to happen in the series... If it actually lasts long enough.
Yeah, nobody would watch this. Remember that one time long ago when they were going to make that stupid show that takes place in an "Office"? Good thing we ignored that, too, huh?The only thing predictable is you and the whiners on this board. You don't need to speak because we already know what kind of man you are. And that's why we know enough to ignore you.
All I have to say is this... How long did the new Bionic Woman and Knight Rider shows last? How long did The Cape last? And Terra Nova? NBC has enough trouble keeping new programming going to begin with... Make it anything remotely sci fi and it gets even worse. And for the record, The Office was a hit because of top writers and it was an adaptation of a hit british TV series of the same name.
Bionic Woman and Knight Rider honestly were terrible so I see your point there. I never watched The Cape so I can't really give an opinion. Terra Nova was on Fox.


