By Rob Bricken in Comics
Monday, June 18, 2012 at 3:25 pm
Oh, Alan Moore, you scamp!Though the words "Harry Potter" are never mentioned, the allusions are unmistakable. One section features a magical train hidden between platforms at King's Cross station which leads to a magical school. The Antichrist character has a hidden scar and a mentor named Riddle. (Lord Voldemort, born Tom Riddle, is Harry Potter's arch enemy in the Potter series.) Characters resembling both Ron Weasley and Hermione Granger also appear and, at one point, the Potter character kills someone with a lightning bolt from his flaccid penis.
The story threads history and fiction together, taking readers through different periods in British history - 1910, 1969 and finally 2009. The final instalment will see the three main characters, Mina Murray, Allan Quatermain and Orlando attempt to face down the Antichrist.
And that's the news. The most recent LoEG chapter posits a Harry Potter-like character as the Antichrist. That's it. I find that a fascinating idea -- I've also very much been enjoying The Unwritten comic series, which posits a Harry Potter-like character as the savior of reality, so, no disrespect or anything -- and I very much look forward to reading it.
Of course, since this is Alan Moore, somehow the controversy has shifted completely into more arguing about Before Watchmen, as if Moore using a Harry Potter-like character as a villain is at all equivalent to DC pimping out more Watchmen stories. They're not. As usual, Sean T. Collins puts it best:
[These would be the same thing] if and only if Moore released this issue as "BEFORE HARRY POTTER," starring all the actual Harry Potter characters rather than parody versions of them, using the Harry Potter trade dress, through Harry Potter's publisher, exploiting a loophole in a contract he arranged with Rowling, over Rowling's explicit and unequivocal objections, following a two-decade string of mistreatment and broken promises.
I obviously agree. Still, hopefully people will still see what spawned this round of Before Watchmen arguing, and pick up what sounds like the craziest, ballsiest comic of 2012. And if you don't want to talk about that, maybe we could talk about this: Only Alan Moore could write a comic about Harry Potter essentially being the Antichrist and end up causing a controversy about something else entirely. (Via Robot 6)